Islamabad High Court

Chief Justice Dogar warns CDA over repeated failure to implement court orders

IHC gives CDA 15 days to comply in a plot allotment case and submit a report, while indicating its chairman could be summoned personally.

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court has directed the Capital Development Authority to implement an earlier order in a plot allotment case and submit a compliance report within 15 days, with Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar expressing strong displeasure over the authority’s handling of the matter.

Chief justice also indicated that the CDA chairman could be summoned personally, the court was hearing proceedings concerning alleged non-compliance with its directions in the allotment dispute, alongside a related contempt matter involving CDA Member Estate Muhammad Zaman Wattoo.

Barrister Hasnain Haider Thaheem, representing the petitioner, told the court that CDA had called his client for a personal hearing despite the matter being pending before the high court and an earlier judicial order already having been issued.

The chief justice questioned why the authority was conducting another hearing after the court’s directions and expressed concern that its handling of the case was undermining compliance.

CDA’s counsel informed the court that the administrative order in question had been issued by the authority’s deputy commissioner. The chief justice nevertheless emphasised that the court required implementation of its directions and expected the authority to verify the relevant orders and documents itself.

The petitioner’s counsel referred to an order dated June 15 and submitted that contempt proceedings had been initiated after it remained unimplemented for a month. He also maintained that the authority’s approach had remained unchanged across repeated appearances.

CDA Directed to Submit Compliance Report Within 15 Days

The court directed CDA to implement the order and place a compliance report before it within 15 days, before adjourning the hearing.

Wattoo appeared with his counsel, Kashif Malik, and an affidavit was submitted in the contempt matter concerning alleged misrepresentation before the court. According to the hearing account, the chief justice indicated that the underlying case would be addressed first and the Member Estate’s contempt matter considered subsequently.

Earlier Proceedings in Wattoo Contempt Case

The latest proceedings follow a series of hearings over Wattoo’s attendance before the court and the explanation offered for his absence.

In September, reporting on the court’s order stated that Wattoo had been directed to appear personally on September 16 but did not attend the chief justice’s court. The petitioner’s counsel subsequently produced material showing his appearance before another bench that day. The court sought a response and appointed Deputy District Prosecutor Adnan Ali to conduct the contempt proceedings.

During the October proceedings, CDA’s counsel disputed the suggestion that Wattoo had personally claimed illness. The chief justice referred to the account recorded in the earlier court order and directed the official to submit a written response. That dispute over the explanation for his absence became a central issue in the contempt case.

On November 3, the court declined to immediately accept an unconditional apology and indicated that a contempt charge would be framed at the next hearing.

However, at the November 12 hearing, the court deferred framing the charge after Wattoo submitted a fresh unconditional apology. The chief justice directed him to file a supporting affidavit by Tuesday.

In his apology application, Wattoo maintained that his absence resulted from an inadvertent lapse and was not intended to challenge the court’s authority. He also assured the court of future compliance with its directions.

The latest hearing places the immediate focus on compliance in the underlying allotment dispute. The supplied account reports no contempt conviction, sentence or final decision accepting or rejecting Wattoo’s apology.

Hussain Ahmad Ch

Hussain Ahmad Ch is a senior Islamabad-based journalist specializing in judicial, constitutional and government affairs reporting. Currently associated with ARY News, he previously worked with 92 News and BOL News. A media graduate of Riphah International University, Islamabad, he has extensive experience covering the Islamabad High Court, constitutional litigation, significant judicial proceedings and developments within the Establishment Division. He has also held leadership positions, including President, Vice President and Secretary, in the Islamabad High Court Journalists Association, reflecting his longstanding involvement in the capital’s legal journalism community. His reporting focuses on judicial accountability, institutional transparency and public-interest issues. He can be reached at Hussain@islamabadtribune.com

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button