Preliminary post-mortem points to repeated violence in Fatima Asghar case
Medical sources say the initial examination recorded more than 20 injuries on the 13-year-old. Investigative sources say a co-suspect alleged repeated assaults and told police she was examined at Police Lines before being taken to hospital.

ISLAMABAD:A preliminary post-mortem examination of 13-year-old Fatima Asghar documented more than 20 injuries, including recent and older injuries, according to sources at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences. The medical sources said the pattern pointed to repeated physical violence and that the preliminary assessment linked her death to complications from those injuries. The detailed post-mortem report is awaited.
Shams Colony police are investigating Fatima’s death in connection with events at a senior officer’s residence in Islamabad Police Lines, Sector H-11. Police have obtained CCTV footage from the residence and allege it shows Fatima being struck.
Co-suspect Describes Alleged Assaults and Hospital Transfer
Investigative sources said Qari Ali Raza, one of two suspects in custody, told police during questioning that Afshan Ali, the wife of senior officer Muhammad Bin Ashraf, had repeatedly struck Fatima with a stick. The sources said Afshan denied assaulting the girl. An earlier Islamabad Tribune report, also citing police sources, said Afshan acknowledged that she and Ali Raza had sometimes struck Fatima but denied burning her or subjecting her to severe violence.
According to investigative sources, Ali Raza told police that Fatima was first examined by a dispenser at Police Lines after her condition deteriorated. He said she was transferred to a private hospital after the dispenser warned that her condition was serious.
Investigative sources also said police recovered a clothes iron and sticks they suspect were used to injure Fatima. Police had previously reported recovering sticks. The reported recovery of the iron has yet to be independently corroborated. Investigators say the detailed post-mortem report is expected to clarify the nature and extent of Fatima’s injuries.
Two Suspects on Four-Day Physical Remand
Judicial Magistrate Naima Iffat granted police four days’ physical remand of Afshan and Ali Raza on November 16. Police had requested eight days. The court directed investigators to produce both suspects again on November 20.
Shams Colony police registered FIR No. 619/26 under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code on November 15 on the complaint of Fatima’s father, Asghar Ali. He told police that his daughter was studying Quran memorisation and living with relatives at Police Lines. He said he was informed that she had fallen ill and been taken to hospital. After her death, he reported seeing marks on her body and asked police to investigate.
Police sources described Fatima as a domestic worker at the residence. Afshan disputed that account, according to earlier reporting. The question is relevant because Section 3 of the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act, 2022, bars children under 16 from working in a household in any capacity.
The Federal Investigation Agency withdrew Bin Ashraf from his posting as director of its Gujranwala Zone and directed him to report to FIA headquarters in Islamabad. The November 15 notification gave no reason for the decision.



